The Emotional Only Child

September 27, 2005 / by birthorder

The Only Child learns early to deal with difficult situations with emotion. Imagine the two-year-old Only on the floor playing with blocks, getting frustrated because they don't work right. Someone watching wants to help the Only to get them piled right. The Only does not want the intrusion, wants to figure it out and asks the person to not touch anything. But the adult is eager to help until the Only has to scream, flail her arms and express her anger. With that the adult backs off. The child has learned to get things done with emotion.

The Only Child has learned to think with feelings. In the adult Only Child this comes out in remarks such as "I'm not comfortable with that" or "I don't know what I want to do Saturday night because I don't how I'm going to feel." "Never" and "Always" statements are an Only Child expression of emotion as in "You never help me around the house" or "You are always wanting me to do things I don't want to do."

When positive, Only Child emotion can be enjoyed by others. For example, others enjoy it when the Only emotes saying "I just love that outfit." The Only Child laugh can be contagious in a group. The Only Child smile can really make others feel liked.

To put emotions into balance, we can tell the Only "Never get so interested in feelings that you forget to think." This enables the subconscious mind to balance emotion with thought.

17 comments on The Emotional Only Child

  • psychovirus said 3 years ago
    This also makes the Only Child a marvelous dramatic actor/actress!
  • paulcmartens said 3 years ago
    I would disagree with you psychovirus. I think its a 4 which can be someone else or entertain really well. An only might be fun to watch (say, like Kathy Griffin) and even funny, however its a 4 who usually is a better qualified at acting since they have trouble being themselves anyway. Food for thought.
  • birthorder said 3 years ago
    Paul and Psychovirus - you are both right in different ways. The Fourth Born is the best actor to portray personalities. The Only Child is the best actor to express emotions.
  • psychovirus said 3 years ago
    Notice that I said, Dramatic actor. A dramatic actor is one that uses emotion most effectively to convey thoughts/feelings to others. An Only will be the best capable at doing this very thing.

    I agree that the Fourth will be the best overall actor.
  • pmtisu said 2 years ago
    Being an only child I will tell you using emotions to deal with difficult situations alleviates the frustrations. This is not related to not getting what we want but that we can't figure out what is expected from us. There is an unspoken expectation that onlies are to make everyone's life easier and happier; therefore, emotions are the only way we can release our frustrations. IT IS NOT EASY BEING AN ONLY! :)
  • susieann said 6 months ago

    This is so true!!!!Smile

  • birthorder said 2 years ago
    Thank you for sharing that. This is an element of Only Child I have not explored - their feeling that they have to meet others' expectations. I'll be taking a look at that with my clients. Thanks again.
  • onlychild1 said 2 years ago
    Cliff,
    Can you tell more about only child hiding power?
    In July of 2004, you wrote in your first newsletter, "The Only Child core issues are thinking with feelings and hiding power. If you comprehend thinking with feelings you are an Only.
    ...
    The issues for the Only Child personality are that she hides her thinking and hides her power. Next month we'll take a look at First Born core issues. " [end quote from http://www.birthorderplus.com/newsletter/archive/july2004.htm]

    I understand about thinking with feelings so I must be an only child. But this thing about hiding power, I do not understand, and I'd like to. Could you give an example? How can one hide power? Thanks - a fan of yours
  • birthordertherapy said 2 years ago
    An Only Child does not exercise power over others choosing rather to give the other person reasons for doing what the Only Child wants. A parenting example is of the Only Child parent giving a child reasons for going to bed rather than saying "I want you to go to bed" which would be an exercise of power. Adult to adult would be to say "Do you want to go out tonight?" rather that saying "I'd like to go out tonight."

    Thanks for asking. I appreciate your being a fan!

    Cliff
  • onlychild1 said 2 years ago
    Oh - I get it. Thank you very much. I have another question, if you don't mind answering. I took your quiz in one of your books, and came up as primarily only-child personality, secondarily, thirdborn and firstborn. I have a sister who is younger by 3.5 years. Sorry for all the details. I think the following applies to me:
    "A mother under stress when her oldest child is around two years of age can create a Birth Order personality in her child that is not First Born. This means the oldest child can be Second, Third or Fourth because of the mother's interaction with the child.

    The Birth Order created in the child depends not only on Mother's Birth Order but also on the sex of the child. If the child is a boy he takes on the same Birth Order as Mother's. If the child is a girl she takes on the next Birth Order following Mother's.

    With a Second Born mother the daughter becomes Third Born in personality. "
    from http://birthorder.blogster.com/when_mother_causes_birth.html

    The only question I have, is, is it possible to get a secondary birth order characteristic this way? I often remember being helpful and brave and letting my mother's criticisms roll off my back; in a third born way. Normally an only child personality gets the secondary birth order characteristcs of her mother, not the next one down, according to your charts. I am not sure if my mother is a second or only; she was 4 or 5 years younger than her brother and seems a lot more like a second than an only, in vivaciousness, criticism, etc. But 2nd child is the one that comes up least for me in that quiz; as well as with the "sayings" where "Leave me alone, I'd rather do it myself" really hits home; followed by "No problem; that doesn't bother me" and "I don't know, how about you?" - the third and first. Now I know most situations can occur due to variations in situations, but have you ever heard of this occurring before; i.e. mother handing third born personality to daughter due to stress while daughter retains only child personality as primary?
    Thanks, and sorry for the long email. -Still a fan!
  • intjonly said 2 years ago
    I'm a first born with the personality of an only. I have no idea if the"grandma" type relationship occurred when my brother came along, but I suspect that I had attachment issues with my mother and am not close to her. I've always been very independent, and get along much better with my more emotionally stable, laid-back dad. My only sibling brother (15 months younger) is very close to my mother - co-dependant perhaps.

    When there is only one more sibling following an only personality first born, what personality occurs with the younger sibling?
  • birthordertherapy said 2 years ago
    In my experience about one-third of the time an oldest child will be an Only rather than a First Born. This is so common that many researchers describe the First Born as having Only Child characteristics.

    In the case of two children both will be Onlies if the oldest is an Only. There is a pseudo Birth Order difference between the two because the second child wants to be different from the older one when both are Onlies. Despite the apparent differences both are Onlies. There tends to be conflict during childhood that changes into closeness when they are adults.
  • onlychild1 said 2 years ago
    Thank you again. It is interesting to hear of another firstborn only, with only 15 months in between. I am the oldest and would say I am the one with codependency on my mother...my sister is more aloof, although I guess I have been aloof too...I had had questions about the second born personality in the second sibling after an only child only. My sister has many of those, attention to detail, criticism, sociability, etc; but the part about there being a lot of friction is right on. I have to hold back from going to her and trying to "make up" because this is an oldest child personality thing; and something I am not comfortable with; the amount of effort it takes to make our relationship work is almost too much; and I have given up many times and been shocked by her behavior; I am sure mine is equally shocking, when I think about it. "Fighting over minutiae" as Cliff writes seems right on. Thanks Cliff, again.
  • onlychild1 said 2 years ago
    Can you tell us more about the pseudo-birth order characteristics of the two or more only children personalities in the same family? Can these replace the secondary birth order characteristics we are supposed to get from our parents? If not would not that make three extra birth orders, beside the only: the "pseudo" and those gained from both parents (if different)? Thanks, a fan.
  • jasonfreely said 2 years ago
    My girfriend is an only child and I'm wondering if you are familiar with other birth order types because I'd like to know if our relationship is built to last. I am older than she is.


    My older brother 7 1/2 years older than me
    my older sister 6 1/2 year older tham me
    I'm male the last.

    What order do I fall into and who would I be compatable with for marriage?
    Am I first, second, or last or only, or do I fall into all three?

    i would like to know if we are going to ride the smooth sails or set off to the rough seas.

    Jason
  • birthorder said 2 years ago
    Jason - that's some good questions. You are probably Third Born in personality. That is a good match with Only Child so according to Birth Order you should have a good marriage. Of course, other factors can affect your relationship.
  • sologirl said 2 years ago
    I am an only child and I am quite the attention hog. I am emotional and often feel jealous or possesive when I get in a relationship. May be the never having to share my mothers attention set me up for this. Also I have always related more to adults instead of with other kids when growing up. Not having a dad around contributed to that also.

Add a comment

To add comments without entering your email and image verification, you must be logged in. Login or Join Blogster

  • Type the words in the box below the image.

Email this blog post to a friend

To email posts to friends, you must be logged in. Login or Join Blogster

Friends

View All